Skip to main content

More than "Moore" to win: Optimization strategies for success in a maturing semiconductor industry

Semiconductor demand remains strong as chips are embedded practically everywhere today; yet, many disruptive trends are pushing companies in this maturing industry to re-examine their business strategies in order to remain viable.
IBM Institute for Business Value study
Last updated: 05 Feb 2009
   Download complete IBM Institute for Business Value study ( 234KB )
Summary
Abstract
Related reports & papers
Related services & products

i
Summary

The impact of higher costs and other key disruptive trends on the semiconductor industry – especially competitive landscape changes, technology convergence and greater global connectedness – mean that traditional business models just no longer work. Nor will the promises of Moore's Law be enough to provide sustained competitiveness. Future success will require innovative changes to existing business models that optimize capabilities in the areas of integration, customer centricity and collaboration.

Back to top
i
Abstract

Industry costs are skyrocketing. The total R&D cost for the semiconductor industry was reported to be US$45 billion in 2006, and analysts believe that it will be US$100 billion by 2010.1 In addition, process development costs for 32nm manufacturing could hit US$3 billion, which is twice the cost for 65nm process technologies.2 This does not include other development costs such as new chip fabrication facilities ("fabs"), new processes, tools and equipment.

Market indicators show the industry is, in fact, maturing. Revenue growth has slowed dramatically in the past two decades (see Figure 1). The five-year compound annual growth rate (CAGR) for industry revenue dropped from more than 15 percent in 1990 to less than 4 percent by 2005.

Figure

And yet, in today's world of pervasive computing, it seems chips can be embedded practically everywhere. It used to be that Moore's Law – a 1965 prediction by Gordon Moore that the number of transistors on a chip would double every one to two years – offered strong hope of lower costs and continued prosperity for chip makers.3 But today's hard truth is that it now takes more than "Moore" to win. To better understand current industry trends and their impacts, as well as how to win in this new environment, IBM conducted the 2007 Semiconductor Industry Optimization Study (SOS). This in-depth study of the top 60 semiconductor suppliers, which include companies that manufacture their own chips (Integrated Device Makers or "IDM") and companies that design but do not manufacture chips (fabless) and four top foundry players, is based on face-to-face interviews, analysis of financial results and industry best practices, along with other secondary research.

Our research and discussions with industry leaders led us to the conclusion that the maturing industry means companies must re-examine their business strategies and specifically, their business models. Indeed, companies should not only look for a new "super application" or cutting-edge technology to achieve the next level of growth, but they also need to determine what changes are needed to help them improve their financial returns in an industry facing significant disruption.

The seven Cs: Disruptive industry trends
Seven disruptive trends – we call them the "seven Cs" – are reshaping industry players, their relationships within the ecosystem, and the value chain itself. These forces include complexity, commoditization, consumerization, along with four others that we examine more closely in our full paper:

  • Cost: Doing business is more expensive across the board.
  • Competition: The industry is in flux.
  • Convergence: Semiconductors are the common "fabric" binding digital content.
  • Connectedness: A flatter world is bringing people closer.

Optimization strategies
With the seven Cs and so much resulting industry volatility, the proven strategies of the past may bring failures in the future. As companies navigate in today’s rapidly changing global business environment, their ability to shift direction and introduce business model innovation is proving to be a critical success factor. These approaches to business model innovation can either be used alone or in combination.

  • Industry model – Innovation in the "industry value chain."
  • Enterprise model – Innovation in the structure of the enterprise and the role it plays in new or existing value chains, focusing on redefining organizational boundaries.
  • Revenue model – Innovation in how companies generate revenues by reconfiguring offerings (product/service/value mix) and by introducing new pricing models.

Choosing the right course of business model innovation is only one part of the equation. A key set of business capabilities must also be developed, including:

  • Centricity: Strengthen connections with both customers and end customers.
  • Collaboration: Aim for radical collaboration by thinking and acting "big."
  • Integration: Tighten ecosystem integration to bring differentiated value to the end customer.

When it comes to semiconductors, the race for "smaller, faster and cheaper" is still on, but the traditional focus on product and technology innovation alone is not sufficient to survive the seven Cs – especially skyrocketing costs, dynamic competition, digital convergence and greater global connectedness.

How can IBM help?
Strategy and Change: Help to define your strategy and manage change
Component Business Modeling (CBM) tools and Service-Oriented Architecture (SOA): Help with selecting where to focus your organization and building flexible IT infrastructures
Selected Electronics Industry Solutions: Product lifecycle management, Semiconductor production, Value chain management

To read the full report, download the PDF file at the top of this page.

Back to top
i
About the authors
iGeorge Bailey
George Bailey, General Manager, IBM Microelectronics Division

iWendy Huang
Wendy Huang, Managing Consultant, IBM Global Business Services – Americas
Back to top
Related reports & papers

Application management services for the electronics industry: Equipping the enterprise for a new era of growth
Audio interview: Better Consumer Electronics Value from Better Consumer Relationships
Client testimonials
Company gets help to meet key customer integration requirements
IBM Professional Marketplace matches consultants with clients
IBM, Motorola, Syclo and Zebra: Driving efficiency with connected field service workers
IBM: Stand Out from the Consumer Electronics Crowd with First-Class Product Design
Innovation Sourcing: increase business value within outsourcing relationships
Integrated data across Americas first steps to globalization
Who's in charge here? In the world of digital convergence, it's the end user
Get Adobe® Reader®
Back to top

Related services & products
Solutions for the electronics industry
Back to top
Download PDF  234KB
Get Adobe® Reader®
Printable version E-mail this page

We're here to help

Chat now
E-mail us

or call us at
1-800-IBM-7080
Mention 108AE08W


Subscription

Subscribe to IdeaWatch
Sign up to receive monthly e-mail updates, including IBM Institute for Business Value studies and other fresh thinking from our consultants

RSS feed from IBM
Get business and IT insights from IBM Global Services, delivered direct to you via RSS

Podcast series
Listen to our executive reports at work or on the go