Skip to main content

Plugging in the consumer: Innovating utility business models for the future

The utility industry is undergoing tremendous change as historically passive ratepayers migrate into more participatory roles.
IBM Institute for Business Value study
Last updated: 19 Jan 2009
   Download complete IBM Institute for Business Value study ( 254KB )
   Download executive summary ( 115KB )
Summary
Abstract
Related reports & papers

i
Summary

Historically, the relationship between utilities and consumers has been rather lopsided – utilities had the power, both literally and figuratively. But the confluence of climate change concerns, rising energy costs and technology advances leading to greater consumer involvement is now radically redefining that relationship. Our recent surveys of 1,900 energy consumers and nearly 100 industry executives across the globe reveal major changes underway – a more heterogeneous consumer base, evolving industry models and a stark departure from a decades-old value chain. We believe companies need to prepare now for a participatory network that enables customers to choose from a wide variety of suppliers, actively manage their consumption and even sell back surplus power they generate.

Back to top
i
Abstract

In decades past, as long as the energy flowed when and where required, residential and small commercial customers were satisfied with leaving all the decisions about their energy supply to their trusted providers, even if they were unhappy with the bill. But times have changed. Growing reliability concerns, fear for the environment's future, and ever higher energy bills have some consumers wanting to manage more of their energy supply decisions themselves. If utilities and regulators allow them to be more active participants, these customers are willing to shoulder more responsibility.

Given this shift in consumer attitudes and the rapid advancement of new technologies, what will the industry look like in five to ten years? How quickly will utilities and regulators respond to these emerging consumer needs? And how much control do consumers really want?

To help answer these kinds of questions, we surveyed 1,900 consumers from six countries in mature economies. In our 'consumer' group, we included residential households and small commercial customers, but excluded large commercial and industrial companies. We also interviewed nearly 100 industry executives in Europe, North America and the Asia-Pacific region – one-third from large firms with revenues greater than US$5 billion and the remainder from smaller utilities.

Based on the insights from our consumer survey, interviews with utility executives and investors, and our own consulting experience, we anticipate a steady progression toward a Participatory Network, a technology ecosystem comprising a wide variety of intelligent network devices, distributed generation and consumer energy management tools. In the interim, before the necessary technology, consumer interest and regulatory enablers are fully in place, utilities may move to one of the other possible utility models: Passive Persistence, Operations Transformation or Constrained Choice (see Figure).

Figure 1

In anticipation of these shifts, we believe utilities will need to reevaluate how they segment and serve customers. Substantial changes in how the industry generates value should also be expected, as revenue models move from being centered solely on energy flows to focusing on both energy and information. Burgeoning information flows and evolving consumer demands will attract a new cadre of competitors eager to take their share of new product, service and business model opportunities. Leveraging the new technology ecosystem will help companies harness innovation to meet their objectives.

Leveraging the new technology ecosystem will help utilities harness innovation to meet key objectives in coming years, including:

  • Preparing for an environment in which customers are more active participants
  • Capitalizing on new sources of realtime customer and operational information, and deciding which role(s) to play in the industry's evolving value chain
  • Better understanding and serving an increasingly heterogeneous customer base.

The utility industry is fast approaching a tipping point beyond which consumers can, and increasingly will, demand equal footing with their providers. Those utilities that are fully prepared to share responsibility with their customers and help them meet their specific energy goals will have a significant competitive advantage.

How can IBM help?
Strategy and Change, Business Model Innovation, and Intelligent Utility Maturity Model: Help you define a company-specific strategy for moving toward a Participatory Network, and manage change as the key industry drivers evolve
Component Business Modeling (CBM) tools and Service-Oriented Architecture (SOA): Help with selecting where to focus your organization and building flexible IT infrastructures for the future
Selected Energy and Utilities Solutions and Offerings: Intelligent Utility Networks (Advanced Meter Management and Network Automation Analytics), Customer Operations Transformation and Power Generation Optimization

To read the full report, download the PDF file at the top of this page.

Back to top
i
About the authors
iMichael Valocchi
Michael Valocchi, Global Lead Partner, Energy and Utilities, IBM Global Business Services

iAllan Schurr
Allan Schurr, Vice President, Strategy & Development, IBM Global Energy and Utilities Industry

iJohn Juliano
John Juliano, Consultant, Utilities industry

iEkow Nelson
Ekow Nelson, Communications Sector Leader, IBM Institute for Business Value
Back to top
Related reports & papers

Beyond the carousel: Better baggage handling through enhanced collaboration among airlines and airports
Changing lanes for success: Flexible automotive business models in times of accelerated change
Economic development in a Rubik's Cube world: How to turn global trends into local prosperity
How the most advanced nations can remain competitive in the Information Age: Leveraging information and communications technologies for national economic development
Inside India: Indians view their automotive future
Market-based Government Through Innovation: How public sector leaders are improving collaboration and focusing on citizens
Succeeding in the new economic environment: Focus on value, opportunity, speed
TD Waterhouse invests in improved customer service with IBM and KANA
U.K. Ministry of Defence rationalizes IT spending with an on call logistics support team
Winning in China's mass markets: New business models, new operations for profitable growth
Get Adobe® Reader®
Back to top

Download PDF  254KB
Get Adobe® Reader®
Printable version E-mail this page

We're here to help

E-mail us

or call us at
1-800-IBM-7080
Mention US7AN05T


Energy & utilities consulting
Energy & utilities consulting

Services to fuel success for energy and utilities companies

Learn more


IBM Energy & utilities
IBM Energy & utilities homepage

Solutions for the energy and utilties industry

Learn more


Subscription

Subscribe to IdeaWatch
Sign up to receive monthly e-mail updates, including IBM Institute for Business Value studies and other fresh thinking from our consultants

Podcast series
Listen to our executive reports at work or on the go

RSS feed from IBM
Get business and IT insights from IBM Global Services, delivered direct to you via RSS