Skip to main content

Identifying what should be changed: How public officials and military leaders can choose wisely

Component business modeling techniques can help government agencies and the military in mapping our changes to adapt to shifting needs in their missions and structures.
IBM Institute for Business Value study
Last updated: 05 Jul 2007
   Download complete IBM Institute for Business Value study ( 327KB )
Summary
Abstract
Related reports & papers
Related services & products

i
Summary

Public officials and military leaders are operating today in an environment of significant change in the mission, requirements, structure and work of their departments and agencies. Assessing what to change – and how – are such daunting and complex tasks that they have turned to a whole new generation of strategic frameworks and analytical tools useful in both public and private organizations. By using strategic frameworks and analytic tools, officials can provide decision makers with the rationale and justification for innovative and thoughtful changes to their organizations.

Back to top
i
Abstract

The need for change
Changes in national budgets, in conjunction with global business and technology trends, and emerging security threats are impacting governments across the world. Defense organizations are particularly being required to quickly shift priorities to meet these threats and to collaborate realtime across services and with allies.

At the same time, citizens are demanding their governments be ever more responsive to their needs. Officials are also facing the crisis of redesigning, downsizing or merging whole agencies and departments while large numbers of employees with crucial knowledge and experience become eligible to retire.

Facing substantial change, senior officials are renewing their focus on improving services, outcomes and performance by modernizing their organizations. However, they also know from prior experience that it does not always work to bring private sector practices into government without modification.

Although both private and public sector leaders understand the importance of formal planning and operating flexible enterprises, they approach innovation and change differently (see Figure 1).

Figure 1

How can leaders facilitate change?
Government leaders are now using modeling frameworks to look at their organizations in more detail and view them as collections of activities, skills, resources, and infrastructures. An example of this organizational decomposition process is what we call component business modeling (CBM) and involves creating a model of an organization's parts, which can be used to understand the gaps between strategy and operations.

Building a component model, or business map, enables managers to frame decisions based on the broader perspective of the entire organization and helps them identify those areas that, if changed, offer the greatest opportunity for improvement or innovation.

What can be gained from business mapping analysis?
Leaders within departments or agencies can use a business mapping analysis to create an objective, high-level, prioritized view of what has to change in an organization. Participants can understand the implications and ripple effects of proposed changes – such as what should be changed sooner rather than later – and can identify which agencies would be affected.

Management accumulates empirical data useful for decision making that offers both transparency and traceability of information and thinking. Such data helps address crucial questions about how particular decisions were made. What were the criteria? And, why did initiatives not receive funding?

The decision making process is enhanced. For example, multiple layers of officials can participate in a structured way in decision making and learn how to reach key decisions. Leaders and managers can begin to tackle problems throughout the organization and address all the usual dependencies and handoffs that must be dealt with. Investments in people, systems and other assets can be driven by and aligned with the most compelling requirements of an agency or department.

Formal techniques are enhancing collaboration
Civilian and military leaders have long embraced formal managerial techniques to operate their complex organizations. In recent years, using techniques to describe their organizations as components of a large administrative ecosystem is proving useful in a broad range of circumstances. The move to such tools is evident globally.

When entire governments have to collaborate at operational levels, commonly used techniques can be applied, as demonstrated by the experiences of members of the European Union, and by militaries and border management agencies that need to coordinate their daily activities within a nation, or around the world.


To read the full report, download the PDF file at the top of this page.

Back to top
i
About the authors
iJames W. Cortada
James W. Cortada is a member of the IBM Institute for Business Value, where he leads teams that conduct research on the key issues facing governments around the world.
iMolly Hamon
Molly Hamon is a Senior Managing Consultant with the Technology Strategy practice within IBM Global Business Services and is a consultant to government agencies.
iLisa Yarbrough
Lisa Yarbrough is an Associate Partner with IBM Global Business Services and manages the CBM Solutions Group within the Technology Strategy practice.
Back to top
Related reports & papers

Electronic filing of land registry documents saves time and costs
Florida State University Panama City puts experts and investigators "on site" at underwater crime scenes in real time
Full transparency in the Municipality of Hørsholm
How nations thrive in the Information Age: Leveraging information and communications technologies for national economic development
IBM digital video surveillance: In-car computing for delivering intelligence
IBM On Demand Workplace for Government Executive Brief
Podcast Interview: E-readiness rankings 2008: Maintaining Momentum
Podcast Interview: Intelligent Transport: How Cities Can Improve Mobility
Storstrøms ErhvervsCenter uses the power of pervasive computing to prevent hypertension and falls
Victoria Police improves safety and operational efficiency with a mobile data network
Get Adobe® Reader®
Back to top

Related services & products
Solutions for the government industry
Back to top
Download PDF  327KB
Get Adobe® Reader®
Printable version E-mail this page

We're here to help

Chat now
E-mail us

or call us at
1-800-IBM-7080
Mention 108AE08W


Subscription

Subscribe to IdeaWatch
Sign up to receive monthly e-mail updates, including IBM Institute for Business Value studies and other fresh thinking from our consultants

Podcast series
Listen to our executive reports at work or on the go

RSS feed from IBM
Get business and IT insights from IBM Global Services, delivered direct to you via RSS