Skip to main content

Winning the global challenge: The Japanese electronics companies' race to innovate

Learn about the competitive challenge facing Japanese electronics companies and steps they can take to become global innovators.
IBM Institute for Business Value study
Last updated: 19 Jan 2009
   Download complete IBM Institute for Business Value study ( 233KB )
   Download executive summary ( 128KB )
Summary
Abstract
Related reports & papers
Related services & products

i
Summary

In the past, Japanese electronics companies (JECs) were able to maintain their competitive advantage in the global marketplace by focusing on product innovation. However, competitors in other parts of the world are now outperforming JECs in terms of productivity, financial performance and brand value. To win the global challenge, JECs need to race toward becoming global innovators and focus on a five-pronged transformation.

Back to top
i
Abstract

For decades, Japanese electronics companies have dominated the global electronics industry. Their brands were hallmarks for quality, style and especially innovation. In fact, looking back over the top ten U.S. patent holder lists since 1999, at least five of the ten companies recognized each year have been JECs.1

Unfortunately, technological prowess in product innovation alone has not been enough to keep JECs ahead of their global competitors. Globalization, electronics industry trends such as product commoditization, and increased global competition are reshuffling the industry's leading contenders, with fewer JECs remaining in the top tier.

Though this situation is obviously difficult for the JECs involved, its impact may reach much further – upstream to suppliers as well as across the national and global economies. Currently, electronics is the leading contributor to Japan's gross domestic product – even higher than the automotive industry; the Japanese economy, in turn, is the second largest in the world.2 The ripple effect of a continued decline could be staggering.

JECs face a tremendous global competitive challenge. Rivals across the rest of the world (ROW) are currently outperforming them in terms of productivity, financial performance and brand value. Across each measurement area we examined – including productivity, financial performance and brand value – JECs trailed their counterparts in other parts of the world. For example, although JEC revenue continues to grow incrementally year to year, the ROW's revenue is growing four times as fast (see Figure 1). That means, JECs' share of the global electronics market is shrinking, falling 13 points over the last decade.

Figure 1

During our analysis, we observed instances where an individual JEC was outperforming its global peers. However, when evaluated as a group, JECs are clearly losing their edge. The top spots vacated by JECs leave room for competitors – often South Korean ones – to surpass JECs, taking on more prominent positions in the industry.

Five focus areas for winning the global challenge
For JECs to counteract these trends and become global innovators, we believe five areas of focus will be key: 

  • Customer insight – Develop a deep understanding of both the domestic and international customer to create strong value propositions.
  • Business model innovation – Implement new or updated business models that help them achieve greater value propositions.
  • Global business portfolio management – Establish the ability to shift resources among lines of business (LOBs) and enter/exit businesses fluidly.
  • Global governance and communication – Make decisions efficiently and communicate clearly with stakeholders.
  • Global human resource management – Attract and retain top global talent at a competitive price.

Given their current condition in comparison to competitors worldwide, JECs face a challenging race ahead. Over the past few years, global competitors have learned from watching the strengths – and weaknesses – of their Japanese rivals. It is time for JECs to also learn from the strengths and weaknesses of their global competitors.

JECs have an important advantage over other companies in the electronics industry – their experience and track record in product, technological and manufacturing innovation. But they must build on this core strength. For those JECs that commit to the fundamental changes required to become Global Innovators – and take action now – we see a very bright future. They will be the ones that outpace their global competitors and maintain a formidable advantage in the continuous race to innovate.

To read the full report, download the PDF file at the top of this page.

References
1 IBM Institute for Business Value analysis of IFI's annual top patent company lists from 2000 through 2005.
2 The IBM Institute for Business Value calculated the 2007 GDP contributions using statistical data published by Japan's Cabinet Office.

Back to top
i
About the authors
iGeorge Bailey
George Bailey is an IBM General Manager and Global Leader of the IBM electronics industry organization.

iWendy Huang
Wendy Huang is a Managing Consultant within the IBM Institute for Business Value, specializing in the Global Electronics Industry.

iShinji Misono
Shinji Misono is a Partner with IBM Global Business Services and is based in Tokyo.
Back to top
Related reports & papers

Adexa Hosted Services
Application management services for the electronics industry: Equipping the enterprise for a new era of growth
Audio interview: Better Consumer Electronics Value from Better Consumer Relationships
Audio interview: Online gaming is not just for kids anymore
IBM Canada Distribution Centre improves functionality with new Warehouse Management Solution
IBM, Motorola, Syclo and Zebra: Driving efficiency with connected field service workers
Not business as usual: Changing channels in consumer electronics
Rebooting the electronics industry: New innovations are vital to address unprecedented economic challenges
Step up your game: Global delivery capabilities for the electronics industry
Taking responsibility, tapping opportunity: How will consumer electronics companies respond to WEEE mandate?
Get Adobe® Reader®
Back to top

Related services & products
Solutions for the electronics industry
Back to top
Download PDF  233KB
Get Adobe® Reader®
Printable version E-mail this page

We're here to help

Chat now
E-mail us

or call us at
1-800-IBM-7080
Mention 108AE08W


Subscription

Subscribe to IdeaWatch
Sign up to receive monthly e-mail updates, including IBM Institute for Business Value studies and other fresh thinking from our consultants

RSS feed from IBM
Get business and IT insights from IBM Global Services, delivered direct to you via RSS

Podcast series
Listen to our executive reports at work or on the go